John Amabile, Brother Of Bachelor In Paradise’s ‘Grocery Store Joe’ Avoids Prison Time In Illegal Gambling Case

Written By Joe Boozell on August 24, 2021Last Updated on September 7, 2021
Chicago Gambling Ring

John Amabile, a former Chicago area police officer, has been sentenced to six months of home detention for his involvement in the Uncle Mick Sports gambling ring.

Amabile confessed to being fully responsible for his role as an agent in the Uncle Mick Sports gambling operation, which also included Casey Urlacher and various other individuals, and was worth millions of dollars.

Amabile expressed his discomfort with being depicted as a predator and mentioned that Terry Kinney, an associate U.S. attorney, recommended a one-year jail sentence for him.

Joe Amabile, also known as “Grocery Store Joe” and a member of The Bachelorette franchise, is the younger brother of his sibling.

The younger Amabile collaborated closely with Gregory Paloian, who was sentenced to 2.5 years in prison in April. They evenly divided their wins and losses and recruited bettors for Uncle Mick Sports.

Paloian has asserted connections to the mob, as did his grandfather Amabile. However, defense attorney George Becker contested the prosecution’s efforts to associate the operation with organized crime in a memo.

Having a last name that ends in a vowel, like John Amabile, does not automatically mean he has ties to the mob. There is no evidence to suggest that John Amabile has ever threatened gamblers who lost money or employed thugs to collect debts.

In November, Amabile declared his resignation as a police agent. U.S. District Judge Martha Pacold stated that authorities fraud is highly perilous.

Unlike Amabile, Nicholas Stella, another former Chicago area police officer, received a 15-month prison sentence for his involvement in the operation. Stella also had other troubling legal problems.

Why Amabile didn’t receive jail day

Judge Pacold referenced Amabile’s efforts to rectify the situation when deciding on the home detention sentence.

After leaving the police department, Amabile and his family transitioned into the logistics business. Since then, he has sold off his assets and managed to repay $52,000 of the $100,000 forfeiture debt.

Amabile stated that he would never again allow himself or his home to be subjected to something like this. He believes that the majority of players bet on sports to enhance their enjoyment of watching the games.

Additionally, Becker wrote:

The court could declare that John Amabile, a former police officer, brought shame upon the law enforcement community and has been sentenced to prison. Alternatively, the judge may acknowledge that Amabile struggles with a gambling addiction and is in need of assistance, despite not being financially destitute.

The defendants implicated in the Uncle Mick Sports ring are facing a range of sentences, including jail time, home detention, and probation.

Why gambling that is legitimate is better

While there is no evidence of Amabile making threats, it is worth noting that his former companion Paloian has a gambling problem. Engaging in improper gambling can have negative consequences, with the most concerning being the potential for physical harm.

In 2004, Paloian was sentenced to 3.5 years in jail for operating a betting business connected to the mob. During that time, he would dispatch mob enforcer Jimmy Inendino to collect debts from individuals who failed to pay their bets.

Bookmakers and onshore sportsbooks often lack rules or safeguards to regulate problematic behavior, allowing companies to take advantage of losing punters without consequences.

On the contrary, legal sportsbooks often encourage responsible gambling practices. Additionally, there are state-sanctioned resources and hotlines available to assist problem gamblers, and gaming regulators carefully evaluate each sportsbook.